Micah’s stagecoach stopped in the middle of the road, and I couldn’t get Arthur off it. I was playing Red Dead Redemption 2 on my PS5 near the end of Chapter 2. We’d already taken the coach. All I was supposed to do was get on and ride with Micah. That was the part where everything went wrong.
The stagecoach bug on video
Watch the 2:37 clip on YouTube. The same stagecoach sequence is in my full PS5 gameplay stream.
What happened when I got on
The mission is An American Pastoral Scene. Micah Bell and Arthur Morgan stop a bank stagecoach near Strawberry. Micah is supposed to drive while Arthur rides beside him. The coach is meant to carry them to the next part of the mission. PowerPyx mission walkthrough.
Arthur and Micah looked like they were sitting almost on top of each other on the front bench. Then Arthur got thrown forward toward the horses. By 0:38 in the clip, you can see him beside the coach, still sitting as if there was a seat under him.

When Micah handed me the Lancaster Repeater, it appeared in Arthur’s hands while he was still in that sitting pose. You can see the rifle by 0:52. I could move again after that, so I climbed back up beside Micah. The coach stayed put. I could look around, but I couldn’t get Arthur off or lock on, and the mission wouldn’t go any further.

By 1:48 I was back on the coach with Micah, and we were still on the same stretch of road at 2:27.

What happened after I closed the game
I closed the game completely and opened it again. My save put me right before the mission, so I could start it from the beginning when I came back. I took a break there. I haven’t retried the mission yet, so I still don’t know whether the coach will move next time.
Other players got stuck with Micah too
The closest report I found was a Reddit thread from January 2019. The player got onto Micah’s coach, then couldn’t make it move. People replying in 2025 and 2026 also described being unable to get off. One player could still aim and fire. In my run, locking on was the part that didn’t work. The thread has mixed results from people trying to force a checkpoint reset. Glitch with Micah mission.
A June 2024 thread describes a stall slightly earlier in the same robbery. The player couldn’t board the coach after taking it. An Xbox player suggested using the mission log to abandon it and retry the checkpoint, or skipping that checkpoint after repeated failures. Another commenter said they got through by restarting from the checkpoint. I haven’t tried either of those on my PS5. Reddit discussion about boarding the stagecoach.
Rockstar’s PS4 and Xbox One patch notes for title update 1.03 mention a bug in this mission where the companion drove the stagecoach in the wrong direction. The notes describe a different symptom from the one I captured, and I couldn’t find an official explanation for the seat overlap or the coach getting stuck in my clip. Rockstar’s title update 1.03 notes.
If you got stuck on Micah’s coach too, I’d like to know where it happened. Could you still get on or off? What were you playing on, and what happened when you reloaded?
